US Navy pays German company $154,400 after losing piracy lawsuit

In short: The US Navy is a pirate, in keeping with the Courtroom of Federal Claims. However this is not the cranium & crossbones, Blackbeard-style of piracy. The army department has misplaced a court docket case over software program copyright infringement and should pay the developer $154,400. But it surely’s not all dangerous information for the Navy: the corporate submitting the lawsuit initially wished $600 million.

German firm Bitmanagement Software program introduced a federal lawsuit in opposition to the Navy again in 2016. The criticism claimed the Navy agreed to license the 3D digital actuality software program BS Contact Geo on a restricted and experimental foundation in 2011 and 2012. The trial concerned putting in this system on 38 computer systems for testing and integration into the Navy’s methods.

So impressed was the Navy with the software program that it allegedly led the developer to consider it deliberate on buying extra licenses for large-scale deployment in 2013. Negotiations occurred between 2013 and 2015, throughout which era Bitmanagement had disabled the copy safety software program on BS Contact Geo on the Navy’s request.

Bitmanagement says that regardless of paying for simply 38 licenses, the Navy put in BS Contact Geo on not less than 558,466 machines. The Flexwrap software program that tracked the variety of duplications was disabled in 2014, so the precise variety of duplicates may have been even larger.

Because the licensing charges for each bit of software program price round $1,067 on the time, Bitmanagement felt it was owed $596 million for the usage of its software program, resulting in a lawsuit in opposition to the federal government. The Navy’s response was a separate court docket submitting claiming that the licenses it bought allowed extra copies to be made with out incurring additional charges. Based on the swimsuit, the Navy uninstalled the BS Contact Geo software program from all of its computer systems and “subsequently reinstalled the software program on 34 seats, for stock functions” after the lawsuit was filed.

The Register writes that Bitmanagement’s unique swimsuit was dismissed in September 2019, solely to be revived by the Federal Circuit in February 2021. The Navy was discovered answerable for copyright infringement as a result of it by no means used a Flexera license administration utility to observe simultaneous customers and determine what number of extra licenses could be wanted, as stipulated by the license phrases.

Importantly, David Kennedy, a Licensed Public Accountant (CPA) for Pricewaterhouse Coopers, determined that the value per license quantities to $200, not $1,067. As such, the decide awarded $154,400 to Bitmanagement. The Navy will even need to pay “delayed compensation” at an undetermined later date.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *